Discussions
Open a thread, read the question, and reply. A new topic can wait for approval before it is public.
Title: Is Sunnah really Independent of Hadith ? Question/Comments: Thanks for your responses. Few questions are raised when your response is seen in perspective of your definition of…
0 repliesEarlier archiveAllegations Against Hazrat Omar (ra)Title: Allegations Against Hazrat Omar ( ra ) Question/Comments: In answering to the allegation that hazrat omarr added "prayer is better than sleep" in the fajer azan, you…
0 repliesEarlier archiveThe Special Position of the Early MuslimsTitle: The Special Position of the Early Muslims Question/Comments: I understand what you mean by the concept of Allah granting sovereignty to the early Muslims as a "promise"…
0 repliesEarlier archiveA Verse about the Refuge of Mariam and Jesus (pbuh) -Al-Mu'minoon 23: 50Title: A Verse about the Refuge of Mariam and Jesus (pbuh) - Al-Mu'minoon 23: 50 Question/Comments: I read a little about this particular refuge of Marry & Jesus…
0 repliesEarlier archiveIslamic Law on LiquorTitle: Islamic Law on Liquor Question/Comments: If a Muslim brother decides to drink wine or another alcohol in a moderate manner, will he be taken to hell-fire in…
0 repliesEarlier archiveRegarding non-Muslims Participating in an Islamic StateTitle: Regarding non-Muslims Participating in an Islamic State Question/Comments: Jazakallah khyar for answering my question. However, please can you clarify whether or not non-Muslims can actually participate in…
0 repliesEarlier archiveFate of the JewsTitle: Fate of the Jews Question/Comments: Why were the Jews not subjected to punishment of death after rejecting Jesus (pbuh) as the prophet of Allah? Mohammad Azam Answer:…
0 repliesEarlier archiveSome more Verses & Comments on JihadTitle: Some more Verses & Comments on Jihad Question/Comments: Ibn Warraq cites the definition of Jihad, as given by T.Hughes in his Dictionary of Islam, and goes on…
0 repliesEarlier archiveAre Muslims directed to Fight and Kill non-Believers? - Al-Nisaa 4: 89 & Al-Taubah 9: 123Title: Are Muslims directed to Fight and Kill non-Believers? - Al-Nisaa 4: 89 & Al-Taubah 9: 123 Question/Comments: One of the objections raised by Ibn Warraq ( http://www.secularhumanism.org/wtc.htm…
0 repliesEarlier archiveAnother Comment on 'Where was Adam?'Title: Another Comment on 'Where was Adam?' Question/Comments: I was reading one of your responses concerning where was Adam (AS) and I commend you on your excellent thoughts.…
0 repliesEarlier archiveA Comment on "Where was Adam?"Title: A Comment on "Where was Adam?" Question/Comments: The paradise was not on earth that is why Allah states: "GET YE ALL DOWN FROM HERE". The statement "I…
0 repliesEarlier archiveA Further Clarification of the Verses on Fasting...Title: A Further Clarification of the Verses on Fasting... Question/Comments: Here is the translation by NJD (N.J. Dawood ) for the verses 186 and 187 of the second…
0 replies