Discussions
Open a thread, read the question, and reply. A new topic can wait for approval before it is public.
Title: Classification of More Directives of the Prophet (pbuh) Question/Comments: Could you please explain how you classify the following directives of the Prophet (pbuh) mentioned in the Hadith…
0 repliesEarlier archiveSome Clarification on Determining Bid`ahTitle: Some Clarification on Determining Bid`ah Question/Comments: Can you explain how you differentiate between a Bid`ah and Jaayiz ? Suppose if one were to say the following statements:…
0 repliesEarlier archiveElaboration of an Objection against the Attitude towards HadithTitle: Elaboration of an Objection against the Attitude towards Hadith Question/Comments: I just wanted to explain my last question to you because you said that you could not…
0 repliesEarlier archiveA Further Clarification...Title: A Further Clarification... Question/Comments: I have read your articles on the difference between Sunnah and Hadith . Please clarify the major difference between the transmission between Sunnah…
0 repliesEarlier archiveIs Hadith source of Shari`ah?Title: Is Hadith source of Shari`ah ? Question/Comments: You wrote in several of responses that writing of Hadiths was never initiated and promoted by Prophet. The following is…
0 repliesEarlier archiveQueries Regarding the Transmission of the Qur'anTitle: Queries Regarding the Transmission of the Qur'an Question/Comments: I read your response regarding nature of transmission of Quran. You wrote The Prophet (pbuh), according to the directives…
0 repliesEarlier archiveRegarding a Comment from Mr. Sam ShamounTitle: Regarding a Comment from Mr. Sam Shamoun Question/Comments: In response to your writing: "Does Semen Emanate from between...", Mr. Sam Shamoun has posted the following comments (at…
0 repliesEarlier archiveFurther Discussion on Qur'anic OathsTitle: Further Discussion on Qur'anic Oaths Question/Comments: Before I ask my question i would like to know the difference between swearing on created things and swearing by created…
0 repliesEarlier archiveScience and IslamTitle: Science and Islam Question/Comments: The Qur'an says: Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before…
0 repliesEarlier archiveWhat, Precisely, is the Evidence for Tawatur?Title: What, Precisely, is the Evidence for Tawatur ? Question/Comments: I was once confronted with the objection that a Muslim must use circular reasoning to legitimate the process…
0 repliesEarlier archiveRegarding the 'Qira'at-al-Aammah'Title: Regarding the 'Qira'at-al-Aammah' Question/Comments: Could you please explain what Qiraat-al-aammah is? Is it the reading done by majority of the Muslims all over the world? In the…
0 repliesEarlier archiveA Comment from Mr. Sam Shamoun...Title: A Comment from Mr. Sam Shamoun... Question/Comments: Hello Fellow Colleagues, I saw your response to my points, which were sent to you by one Faisal. For the…
0 replies