Discussions
Open a thread, read the question, and reply. A new topic can wait for approval before it is public.
Title: Classification of More Directives of the Prophet (pbuh) Question/Comments: Could you please explain how you classify the following directives of the Prophet (pbuh) mentioned in the Hadith…
0 repliesEarlier archiveTimings of PrayerTitle: Timings of Prayer Question/Comments: Could you tell in which category that this forbiddance belongs to? "The Prophet forbade praying after the Fajr prayer till the sun rises…
0 repliesEarlier archiveFurther Questions on SunnahTitle: Further Questions on Sunnah Question/Comments: Please clarify my following doubts on your definition of Sunnah : Since your opinion of Sunnah is not very much in line…
0 repliesEarlier archiveAre Hadiths part of Shari`ah?Title: Are Hadiths part of Shari`ah ? Question/Comments: According to your opinion, Hadiths are not a part of Shariah . Don't you feel that the scope of the…
0 repliesEarlier archiveWhy should Hadith be considered as a part of Islam/Shariah?Title: Why should Hadith be considered as a part of Islam/ Shariah ? Question/Comments: Thus far, you explained in various responses that Hadith is not a primary source…
0 repliesEarlier archiveFurther Clarification regarding the Categorization of the Directives of the Prophet (pbuh)Title: Further Clarification regarding the Categorization of the Directives of the Prophet (pbuh) Question/Comments: The reason behind the forbiddance of Zakat for the progeny of the Prophet (pbuh),…
0 repliesEarlier archiveIs Reciting Surah Al-Faatihah in Prayer a Sunnah?Title: Is Reciting Surah Al-Faatihah in Prayer a Sunnah ? Question/Comments: You explained that even now Sunnah is determined based on consensus of the Muslims. I've come to…
0 repliesEarlier archiveA Further Clarification on the Position of HadithTitle: A Further Clarification on the Position of Hadith Question/Comments: I was just reading your answer on Hadiths and I was wondering: Allah told us (the Muslims) to…
0 repliesEarlier archiveWhy Some things are Considered as Sunnah, while Others are Not?Title: Why Some things are Considered as Sunnah , while Others are Not? Question/Comments: In one of your earlier response You've written that it is forbidden to pray…
0 repliesEarlier archiveMore Questions on SunnahTitle: More Questions on Sunnah Question/Comments: This is further to my question on 'Some Observation on Sunnah ', please clarify my following doubt. God says He will protect…
0 repliesEarlier archiveCategorizing Some of the Directives of the Prophet (pbuh)Title: Categorizing Some of the Directives of the Prophet (pbuh) Question/Comments: Could you please explain in which categories do the following directives of the Prophet (pbuh) mentioned in…
0 repliesEarlier archiveFurther Queries regarding Recitation of Surah-Al-Faatihah in Prayers as a SunnahTitle: Further Queries regarding Recitation of Surah-Al-Faatihah in Prayers as a Sunnah Question/Comments: I am still not very clear regarding the recitation of Surah-AlFathihah during prayers as a…
0 replies