I consider the interpretation given by Amin Ahsen Islahi, in his commentary "Tadabbur-e-Qur'an" to be more logical and, therefore, more acceptable. As explained by Amin Ahsen, it seems that while facing the severest of circumstances the prophet Job (pbuh) uttered some words of objection, which he considered as wavering in his perseverance and, thus, pledged to subject himself to a punishment of flogging after recovering from his ailment. This pledge, even though it was made with the spirit of love, obedience and submission to the Almighty, is not encouraged by God. On the contrary, the path prescribed by God, after one realizes his/her mistakes is that of repentance and correction, rather than inflicting pain on oneself. Nevertheless, because Job (pbuh) had pledged to subject himself to the punishment of flogging, God directed him to honor his pledge by hitting himself with a pack of twigs and also directed him to refrain from making such pledges. I hope this helps. Regards, Moiz Amjad December 12, 2001 Answer published by Moiz Amjad