Is the Use of Anti-depressants Contrary to our Faith in God?
Question
Title: Is the Use of Anti-depressants Contrary to our Faith in God? Question: The use of anti-depressants to alleviate depression is generally discouraged by the Muslims at large. I have the impression that most Muslims feel that their use indicates a weakness in Iman and lack of trust in the Creator. When a bad thing happens to a person, he should be patient as it is a test from God. This is the Islamic interpretation of events in our lives that help us to cope with difficult times. It is understandable then that Muslims would tend to view the use of anti-depressants as an indication that such a belief is lacking, or is weak, which in turn indicates a flaw in one's Iman . However, sometimes a type of depression occurs which has no obvious, discernable cause. This is called "endogenous depression" as it appears to come from no where and is not in response to event in a person's life. Indeed, the person may actually be doing quite well and still be stuck by such a depression. In my view, when depression of this type occurs, the cause of which remains a mystery to doctors, I feel that the use of anti-depressants would not make a comment on the individual's faith in God. It would simply be the medical treatment of an ailment. What are your views on the matter? Atif Abdul Majeed Pakistan Answer: The use of anti-depressants should be seen in the same perspective as the use of any other medication. We, as Muslims, believe that the cure of all diseases is in the hands of God. Medication for diseases - whatever the ailment may be - is not contrary to our faith and trust in God. In fact, on the contrary, all of man's advancements in medicine should only be seen as God's blessing as nothing of the sorts would have been possible without God's will and permission. There is absolutely no reason why psychological imbalances should be seen as an exemption. I hope this helps. Regards, Moiz Amjad February 15, 2003
Answer
Title: Is the Use of Anti-depressants Contrary to our Faith in God? Question: The use of anti-depressants to alleviate depression is generally discouraged by the Muslims at large. I have the impression that most Muslims feel that their use indicates a weakness in Iman and lack of trust in the Creator. When a bad thing happens to a person, he should be patient as it is a test from God. This is the Islamic interpretation of events in our lives that help us to cope with difficult times. It is understandable then that Muslims would tend to view the use of anti-depressants as an indication that such a belief is lacking, or is weak, which in turn indicates a flaw in one's Iman . However, sometimes a type of depression occurs which has no obvious, discernable cause. This is called "endogenous depression" as it appears to come from no where and is not in response to event in a person's life. Indeed, the person may actually be doing quite well and still be stuck by such a depression. In my view, when depression of this type occurs, the cause of which remains a mystery to doctors, I feel that the use of anti-depressants would not make a comment on the individual's faith in God. It would simply be the medical treatment of an ailment. What are your views on the matter? Atif Abdul Majeed Pakistan Answer: The use of anti-depressants should be seen in the same perspective as the use of any other medication. We, as Muslims, believe that the cure of all diseases is in the hands of God. Medication for diseases - whatever the ailment may be - is not contrary to our faith and trust in God. In fact, on the contrary, all of man's advancements in medicine should only be seen as God's blessing as nothing of the sorts would have been possible without God's will and permission. There is absolutely no reason why psychological imbalances should be seen as an exemption. I hope this helps. Regards, Moiz Amjad February 15, 2003
Ask a follow-up
A follow-up appears here only after an editor approves it.